Latest Hunting Forum Topics:

  • Looking for a firing pin for a Armi-Jager AP-80 .22lr? (5 posts)
  • Bolt-action Hunting/long range target shooting? (7 posts)
  • what can my germen shepherd/wolf hunt? (8 posts)
  • Which airgun caliber?.177 vs .22? (7 posts)
  • I would like to get into NFA Guns (Full-Auto) and was wondering what the best way to get into it? (7 posts)
  • Archery In the USA is Hoyt still the best Bow and Y. .? (5 posts)
  • How do i make a pre-charged pneumatic air rifle more powerful? (3 posts)
  • some questions about single action/double action pistols? (8 posts)
  • Desert Eagle? (21 posts)
  • Knife Question? (9 posts)
  • Gun Shows? (7 posts)
  • savage mark II? (3 posts)
  • what do you guys think about a mossberg 100 atr 30-06? 3-9x40 factory mounted scope? (6 posts)
  • hunting with an 8 mm will it drop large game? (8 posts)
  • What Ammo Can I Put In a .38 Special+P Revolver? Besides .38 Special, .38 Special+P, .38 Special+P+, 9 or 9+P? (10 posts)
  •  
    Author Message

    ShoeLover

    Members


    Online status

    104 posts

    Location: Australia
    Occupation: Engraver
    Age:

    #34316   2008-02-29 03:53 GMT      
    What do you think would be a better purchase for home defense and CCW, the new HK45c or a compact 1911 in .45 acp?
    Not a big fan of glocks, great weapon, just not my cup of tea thanks though.

    LazyDogg

    Members


    Online status

    124 posts

    Location: Palestine
    Occupation: Physician Assistant
    Age:

    #34317   2008-02-29 03:59 GMT      
    Do yourself a favor and go with the Glock 36 Slimline.
    It has the slimest profile of any .45 on the market. It takes single stack mags, but you can get extended mags for home, and the stock 6 rounders for CCW. It was an easy chose for me when I bought my carry pistol.

    TigerHen

    Members


    Online status

    109 posts

    Location: Canada
    Occupation: Midwife
    Age:

    #34318   2008-02-29 04:16 GMT      
    what fits your hand best

    BadIan

    Members


    Online status

    114 posts

    Location: Bermuda
    Occupation: Paleontologist
    Age:

    #34319   2008-02-29 05:30 GMT      
    I agree with cooter....Glock 36

    pickapepper

    Members


    Online status

    118 posts

    Location: Kenya
    Occupation: Creative engineering
    Age:

    #34320   2008-02-29 06:27 GMT      
    HK45 all the way. It will go bang every time you pull the trigger, it's accurate, and it will have a picatinny rail for some great home defense accessories (lights, lasers etc...). I don't know of any compact 1911's that have the rail, and on average they are less reliable.

    Have a good 'un.

    BerryNice

    Members


    Online status

    116 posts

    Location: Samoa
    Occupation: Kinesiologist
    Age:

    #34321   2008-02-29 06:28 GMT      
    I'd go with the more modern double-action unless you are just used to the single-action-first-shot and are really comfortable with it. Remember, this involves carrying shell-in-chamber hammer ready to fire or hammer down and you have to remember to pull it back, or chamber empty and rack the slide. In an extreme and stressful situation it is better to just pull the trigger and start the firing process.

    H

    WarmWater

    Members


    Online status

    116 posts

    Location: Puerto Rico
    Occupation: Barista
    Age:

    #34322   2008-02-29 08:40 GMT      
    The Colt Combat Commander in 45 acp.* Well balanced and comfortable to carry and shoot.*

    WarmWater

    Members


    Online status

    116 posts

    Location: Puerto Rico
    Occupation: Barista
    Age:

    #34323   2008-02-29 12:05 GMT      
    I personally prefer a .38 or .357. No fumbling around at zero dark thirty when someone wakes you as they break into your home. Just grab it and start squeezing off rounds. No safety to fumble with, no trying to remember if a round is in the chamber. No jamming.

    Style

    Members


    Online status

    120 posts

    Location: Algeria
    Occupation: karate teacherLaborer
    Age:

    #34324   2008-02-29 13:16 GMT      
    I'm a revolver man but i would go with the M1911

    Snowlilly

    Members


    Online status

    116 posts

    Location: Kuwait
    Occupation: Monk
    Age:

    #34325   2008-02-29 17:37 GMT      
    I would prefer the H&K USP Compact versus a compact M-1911 type pistol.

    Also check my answer to your other related question.
    http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=AjItQczgGJx01uDkitxKJBpQxQt.;_ylv=3?qid=20080229043745AAsDA5r

    Cutefrog

    Members


    Online status

    121 posts

    Location: Greenland
    Occupation: Calligrapher
    Age:

    #34326   2008-02-29 20:49 GMT      
    go with the 1911

    Goldfish

    Members


    Online status

    106 posts

    Location: Sao Tome And Principe
    Occupation: Fletcher
    Age:

    #34327   2008-02-29 20:53 GMT      
    You can't go wrong with a 1911. STI makes a great compact 1911 called The Escort. The Springfield EMP is a 9mm compact 1911 that received Gun Of The Year honors.
    > 1 <